29 January 2019

WHITAKER WHITEWASH




Acting U.S. Attorney General Matthew Whitaker, after rejecting his own Department's Ethics advice to recuse himself from the Mueller investigation, stunned a press conference audience yesterday by announcing that i) he has been "fully briefed" on the investigation, ii) the final Mueller "report" will be reviewed by him, and iii) the investigation is "close to being completed."

The air in St. Barths has a magical quality. From my front porch, I can see the Dutch island of Saba which is more than 15 miles away.  And, remarkably, I can detect bullshit on the horizon, even on rainy days.

Several readers have expressed some alarm at the Whitaker statement, and asked what I could discern from my foreign-shore perch.

So here is the answer to your questions:

First, did Whitaker intentionally mislead when he referred to the Mueller "report" and thereby implied that what was coming was just a report and not one or more indictments? Of course he did.

Second, did Whitaker say that Mueller's investigation was "close to completion" in an effort gin up the Trumpers in Congress to pressure Mueller to end his inquiry? Of course he did.

Third, will this Whitaker/White House bullshit gambit work? Of course it won't.

My bullshit meter does not allow me to change history. So while I cannot undo Whitaker's past errant public statements or inappropriate revelations to the White House, that still leaves me with the ability to see how his bullshit is focused on altering future events.

I can see, on the horizon, the following:

First, Mueller will not be rushed, and he will pursue the investigation until Mueller, not Whitaker, is satisfied that it is complete. Whitaker, who soon is likely to be replaced by Barr anyway, cannot effectively bully or pressure Mueller into shortcutting the inquiry. Mueller has too much integrity and too much support in both houses of Congress.

Second, has Mueller really resigned himself to simply issuing a report? No indictments?  More bullshit.

Some facts:

1. Mueller is no dummy. He wakes up each morning wondering whether he will be fired by a tweet on his way to work. Interesting fact: There are almost three dozen sealed files that were added to the D.C. District Court docket in the last year. That means the docket contains no information about the nature of matter or the parties. Experts say this is an unusually large number of sealed filings, and the prevalent opinion is that some of these are Mueller indictments, already approved by Rosenstein. They are beyond Whitaker's (or Barr's) ability to quash without court approval.

2. Neither Jared nor Junior were questioned by the FBI or have been called to testify before the grand jury. Any criminal lawyer will tell you that is a strong suggestion they are targets. Both made statements to Congress. Did they lie? Does a bear .... ? Are there sealed indictments bearing their names?

3. While Roger Stone was being arrested earlier this week, teams of FBI agents executed search warrants at his homes and his office. Agents were seen carting off computers and electronic devices. It will take a long time to look at that stuff. The first chore will be to have a "clean" team of agents examine it and segregate out any attorney/client or other privileged material. We know from the Cohen searches, that even if that process is accomplished with great efficiency, it could take months to complete. And even when the prosecutors get the non-privileged material, it could take months to read it, digest it, determine if and to what extent if offers up incriminating evidence against Stone and others, or provides investigative leads, etc.

4. If there are pending sealed indictments, or if new indictments are forthcoming, one or more of those defendants may decide to cooperate. That starts the process of new leads, more investigation, perhaps even leading to more indictments.

5. Ahh, then we come to swamp rat Paulie Manafort, formerly business partner to Roger Stone and formerly campaign chairman for Donald Trump. Mueller has charged Paulieboy with abrogating his cooperation agreement by lying to Mueller's team, and Mueller has therefore withdrawn his undertaking to recommend sentencing clemency. Manafort's lawyer told the court his client did not "lie," he just "forgot" lots of things -- y'know inconsequential stuff like giving private Trump polling data to the Russians. He forgot things because, inter alia, he has gout. (Too much red meat in his isolation cell in the D.C. jail?) The judge has scheduled a sealed hearing on Feb 4. There is no telling what will come out of that.

Will the judge write an opinion? Will it persuade Manafort to really spill all this time around? (Unlikely, I think, because Paulieboy is looking for a pardon anyway. But if the judge publishes harsh findings that suggest Manafort cooperated with the Russians during the campaign, does that make a pardon less likely and therefore change the cooperation equation?)

Conclusion:

To this American-in-France, this does not look like an investigation that is either "close to being completed," or likely to conclude solely with a "report."

Then again, as you may have noticed, while so far I have consistently been correct in these matters, I am not exactly what you might call an "objective" observer.

A bientot.



25 January 2019

TRUMP CRIME FAMILY;: ANOTHER SOLDIER OUTED


-->


One of my favorite "small-world" stories is how Mario Puzo, author of "The Godfather," played a significant role in my life. You can read all about it in my memoir, "The Client Decides."

I thought about that this morning when I read Special Counsel Robert Mueller's indictment of Roger Stone for obstruction, lying to Congress, and witness tampering. Stone not only channels Puzo's legendary mob leader, but Stone actually quotes Puzo: Stone urges "Person # 2" ("P2") to "do a Frank Pantangeli," the Godfather II character who, in testimony before Congress, lies by claiming ignorance of facts that he, in fact, knows all about.

Roger Stone is the storied political "trickster" who was so loyal to the last disgraced President that he had a portrait of Richard Nixon tattooed on his back.

Stone told Congress that he communicated to Wikileaks leader Assange about the hacked Democrat emails via his sole intermediary, P2.

P2 was then subpoenaed to testify before Congress. He told Stone he would tell the truth, which would make a liar out of Stone on several counts. The Mueller indictment charges that when P2 so informed Stone, he urged  P2 not only to emulate Puzo's fictional Frank Pantangeli, but to follow the advice of Stone's real-life idol: in an email to P2, Stone quoted advice earlier given to co-conspirators by Richard Nixon: "Stonewall it. Plead the Fifth. Anything to save the plan."

Stone was questioned by two Congressional committees about the Russia interference with the 2016 election. He arrogantly denied having any correspondence, emails, texts, or other material relating to the Wikileaks publication of hacked Democratic Party emails. Indeed, he swore there was no such documentation, that all of his communications on the subject were oral.

But the Special Counsel indictment proves that the Stone testimony was a lie, and quotes from a score of relevant emails and texts written and received by Stone. Included in that trove are Stone's communications:

i) With "senior Trump campaign officials" regarding releases Wikileaks might have that would damage the Clinton campaign. Included was an email wherein Stone was "directed by a senior Trump Campaign official to inquire regarding further releases", and Stone's responses to the Trump campaign reporting the potential for future releases of damaging material.

ii) With both Person #1 ("P1")  and P2 seeking to give information to Assange, and get information from Assange,

iii) With P2, urging him to lie to the Congress and the FBI about his communications with Stone, or take "the Fifth" to protect Stone's lies,

iv) With P2, bullying and threatening P2. When the latter displayed reluctance to follow that advice, and instead urged Stone to go back to Congress and correct his lies:

a) Stone urged the witness not to talk to the FBI, not to be "a rat, a stoolie." [Once upon a time,"Rat" was slang used by fictional mob figures to describe stool pigeons. Now it appears to be standard English used by public official mobsters, when talking about their stoolies:  see e.g., Richard Nixon (John Dean), Donald Trump (Michael Cohen.)]

b) When P2 continued to resist Stone's admonitions to lie and/or stonewall, Stone turned up the heat. He threatened to "take your dog away from you," and he told him to "Prepare to die [expletive deleted]."


So Stone was arrested, required to post $250,000 bail, and surrender his passport. Coming out of court, he gave a Nixonian salute and vowed he would not testify against the President. 

Meanwhile, mysteries abound:

Who is P2, the person who unsuccessfully urged Stone to purge his perjury and got threatened to have his dog stolen, and worse? Press reports suggest P2 is a New York comedian/radio host named Randy Credico. Hard to figure how he is involved with this crowd, but there it is.

Who is P1? Jerome Corsi, the right-wing birther conspiracy theorist who formerly worked for Alex Jones' Infowars, says it is he. So far, Corsi has rejected a plea deal and cooperation offer from Mueller, but is openly accusing Stone of lying about their relationship. Corsi is also suing Mueller, the FBI, the Department of Justice, the CIA, the NSA, the Washington Post and its owner Jeff Bezos for 1.6 Billion Dollars.

Who is the lawyer-friend of P2, who had the ability to speak directly to Assange, and whom Stone threatened to have disbarred if P2 didn't play ball? 

And who is the "high-ranking member of the Trump Campaign" with whom Stone exchanged emails on the subject of the Wikileaks' release of hacked Democrat emails? Bannon? Donald Jr.? The President?

Is there more to come? Is Roger Stone the sought-after conduit between the Trump campaign and Wikileaks? 

And what is the connection between Stone and his correspondence-pal Gucifer 2.0, the Russian intelligence operative credited with the hack and providing the anti-Hillary information to Wikileaks? This indictment does not go there at all. What's up with that?

And If Mario Puzo had written a novel about this confusing but basically not-really-in-doubt grand conspiracy, would the publisher have rejected it as being beyond belief?

And none of this, of course, deals with the follow-the-money track of the Mueller inquiry.

Confused yet?

My end-of-the-day reaction? I liked title of this film, but I find the guts of it disappointingly thin gruel. More early-game Mueller maneuvering. But hey, Mr. Mueller knows a lot more about this than I do. My chips are on him.

Stay tuned. We are nowhere near the final scenes of this movie.

A bientot.


21 January 2019

TRUMP, ALICE, AND OUR DEMOCRACY

The following is the sequence of events. Real events, not Trumpisms.

1. In 2016, during the campaign, Trump made a number of statements indicating a pro-Russia, pro-Putin attitude: He urged reducing the sanctions on Russia that Obama imposed when our intel agencies discovered Russia's interference with our elections, he criticized NATO, praised Putin, minimized Putin's propensity to murder his adversaries, ("We kill people too!") etc.

2. When challenged that these statements might be prompted by Russia business prospects,Trump denied his views were influenced by personal financial considerations. Again and again, he said he had no deals with Russia, and had "nothing going on there." 

3. Trump's campaign statements were lies. In fact, negotiations for a Trump Moscow Tower actually continued throughout the campaign.

3. In 2017, Trump's lawyer Michael Cohen gave Congressional testimony in congruence to the Trump campaign lies: Cohen swore to the Senate that the Moscow Tower negotiations had ended in January.

4. In 2018, Cohen pleaded guilty to having lied to Congress by repeating those Trump campaign lies.  The Mueller indictment of Cohen revealed the Moscow negotiations went on through at least the summer of 2016.

5. Last week, BuzzFeed rocked the country by reporting that Mueller's prosecutors had documentary evidence proving Trump told Cohen to lie to Congress about the status of those negotiations. Mueller's office promptly issued an obscurely worded statement saying that "BuzzFeed's description of specific statements to the Special Counsel's Office, and characterization of documents and testimony obtained by this office, regarding Michael Cohen's Congressional testimony are not accurate." 

6. BuzzFeed responded by saying "We remain confident in the accuracy of our story" and "we urge Special Counsel to make clear what he is disputing." In a subsequent interview on MSNBC, BuzzFeed Editor-in-Chief Ben Smith reported they had given the story to Special Counsel 24 hours before publication, and Mueller's office did not respond. Smith again called upon the Special Counsel to be more specific about what he was saying. Smith repeated that BuzzFeed stood by the story. This time around, Smith avoided ascribing the leak to Mueller's office, and instead said the sources for the report were "two federal law enforcement officials." If the guts of the BuzzFeed story are true, this is a distinction without a difference.

7. Trump categorically denied he told Cohen to lie.

8. Clown Giuliani then took to the airwaves. As is his wont, he basically undercut his client's position. He said i) Trump had admitted, in his written responses to Mueller, that --contrary to Trump campaign statements,-- Trump was aware of Cohen's continued negotiations on his behalf for the Moscow tower right up to October/November 2016, ii)Trump did not tell Cohen to lie to Congress, BUT, get this,  iii) Trump spoke to Cohen about the Moscow negotiations before and after Cohen's perjurious testimony, --"right up to October, November"-- and "if he spoke to him about his testimony he would have would have told him to tell the truth" and iv) Trump believed the Cohen testimony to be true!

It's one thing to lie about the size of an inauguration crowd, but now we have truly turned logic and truth on its head. I gotta repeat  this:  
Trump is now saying,

      i) Trump knew Cohen continued to negotiate for a Trump Moscow tower through November, 2016, 

     ii) Trump therefore knew Cohen lied when he told Congress the negotiations ended in January, and 

     iii) Trump believed that Cohen's testimony was true!

Down the rabbit hole we go: Trump knew Cohen was lying but believes the lies are true.

The Donald channels Alice:

"“Why, sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast."

A bientot, my friends. Not to worry: Mitch McConnell is on the job.